Short answer: The KMI panel judged penalties awarded to Crystal Palace against Liverpool and Ipswich against Bournemouth incorrect, but said neither met the threshold for VAR intervention. Its members assess the original decision separately from a possible review, taking the referee's account and available footage into consideration.
BBC Football reports a joint-record six referee errors across the last Premier League weekend. The panel's findings also show why an error on the pitch and an error by VAR are not necessarily the same thing.
Two penalties, two separate judgments
Crystal Palace's stoppage-time penalty against Liverpool followed Milos Kerkez's challenge on Dario Osorio. All five panellists considered the award incorrect, describing the contact as inevitable. Yet all five also backed no VAR intervention because they did not consider it a clear and obvious error.
Ipswich's penalty against Bournemouth produced a less unanimous assessment. Four panellists considered the award incorrect after Abdoul Ouattara stepped across Lewis Cook, who the panel said had not made a challenge. Four also backed no VAR intervention.
| Incident | On-field decision judged incorrect | No VAR intervention |
|---|---|---|
| Palace penalty vs Liverpool | 5 of 5 | 5 of 5 |
| Ipswich penalty vs Bournemouth | 4 of 5 | 4 of 5 |
| Barry goal for Everton vs Coventry | 3 of 5 | 5 of 5 |
The table separates the two questions rather than treating a wrong on-field call as automatic grounds for a review. In the Ipswich case, the panel was split on both questions; the source does not identify how individual members voted across them.
Why the VAR threshold matters
The KMI panel first assesses the referee's decision against the laws and the Premier League's expected interpretation. Its separate VAR vote considers what the referee said, the replay angles available and the high bar for intervention.
That distinction also shaped the assessment of Thierno Barry's 61st-minute goal for Everton against Coventry. A majority judged the on-field decision incorrect after a potential handball, but every panellist supported no VAR intervention: the panel said the readily available footage did not provide conclusive evidence.
The panel also found a majority view that Bournemouth's Marcus Tavernier should have received a second yellow card for delaying a restart. VAR intervention was not possible for that incident, according to the BBC report.
Other incidents divided the panel
Not every high-profile incident was classified as an error. A 3:2 majority backed the on-field decision and VAR outcome after Leeds defender Jayden Bogle caught Tottenham's Mathys Tel on the ankle. Two panellists thought the challenge was dangerous enough for a red card.
In Chelsea's match against Sunderland, a 4:1 majority backed the decision and VAR outcome after Luke O'Nien challenged Cole Palmer. The majority considered the foul outside the penalty area; one panellist placed the contact inside.
For analysing matches, the practical distinction is that panel criticism of a referee does not by itself establish that VAR should have changed the outcome. The votes, footage and applicable intervention threshold all matter when interpreting an incident.
FAQ
Why was Crystal Palace's penalty against Liverpool not overturned?
The KMI panel unanimously judged the penalty award incorrect, saying contact between Milos Kerkez and Dario Osorio was inevitable. However, all five members also supported no VAR intervention because they did not regard the decision as a clear and obvious error.
Did the panel think Everton's goal against Coventry should have stood?
A 3:2 majority judged the on-field decision incorrect after a potential handball by scorer Thierno Barry. However, the panel unanimously backed no VAR intervention, saying the readily available footage did not provide conclusive evidence.