Short answer: The average big-six club earned £442m more than Everton in 2024-25, up from a £120m gap in 2009-10, according to BBC Sport. Stronger commercial income helps explain the divide, while Champions League distributions give historically successful clubs another financial advantage. Chelsea, however, trails its big-six rivals on revenue.
Everton offer a useful reference point for measuring the Premier League's financial divide. BBC Sport reports that the gap between their revenue and the big-six average has widened sharply since 2009-10, despite their long-standing place in the top flight.
The commercial gap behind the headline
The comparison is not simply about television money. Commercial deals represent 45% of the big six's revenue, compared with 10% at Everton. Broadcasting, meanwhile, accounts for 66% of Everton's revenue, leaving the club more dependent on that source.
| Metric | Reported figure |
|---|---|
| Big-six average revenue gap over Everton, 2009-10 | £120m |
| Big-six average revenue gap over Everton, 2024-25 | £442m |
| Commercial share of big-six revenue | 45% |
| Commercial share of Everton revenue | 10% |
| Broadcast share of Everton revenue | 66% |
University of Liverpool football finance professor Kieran Maguire told BBC Sport that major clubs' global fanbases appeal to sponsors and other commercial partners. The league's broadcast reach across 190 countries supports those negotiations.
BBC Sport expects Everton's move to Hill Dickinson Stadium to change their revenue mix. The comparison nevertheless shows why closing the overall gap involves more than matching established clubs in one area of income.
Europe can widen the financial divide
Aston Villa and Newcastle have increased their revenue, largely thanks to the financial rewards of Champions League participation, according to BBC Sport. But participation does not mean clubs receive the same amount from every part of the competition's distribution.
BBC reports that the Champions League's value pillar reserves 35% of revenue, or £713m, for historically successful clubs. At the end of last season's league phase, Manchester City's estimated value-pillar earnings stood at £37.9m, compared with Newcastle's £13.6m.
Liverpool's estimate was £35.5m and Chelsea's £33.3m. Villa's improved coefficient, helped by last season's Europa League win, puts their projected value-pillar payment at £25m this season, although BBC says that would still trail the big-six clubs in the competition.
The figures describe different stages and seasons: last season's estimates are not directly interchangeable with Villa's current projection. They do show how historical standing can affect the financial reward attached to European participation.
Chelsea's smaller stadium creates a different problem
Even within the big six, the revenue picture is uneven. Chelsea recorded the group's lowest revenue in the past two seasons. BBC reports that they were £74m behind Tottenham and £200m below Liverpool and Manchester City.
Stamford Bridge holds 40,000, while the other big-six grounds each hold at least 60,000. BBC identifies the lack of an easy expansion route as a constraint for Chelsea: a global commercial profile and European income do not erase every disadvantage.
FAQ
How much revenue separates Everton from the Premier League big six?
The gap between Everton and the big-six average was £442m in 2024-25, according to BBC Sport. In 2009-10, the equivalent gap was £120m. The comparison uses the average for the group, rather than the revenue of a single club.
Why does Newcastle receive less value-pillar money than Manchester City?
BBC Sport says the Champions League value pillar allocates money to historically successful clubs. At the end of last season's league phase, City were estimated to have earned £37.9m from it, while Newcastle's estimated share was £13.6m.
Why is Chelsea's stadium relevant to its revenue?
Stamford Bridge has a capacity of 40,000, compared with at least 60,000 at each of the other big-six grounds. BBC Sport says expansion is not straightforward and identifies the stadium as a problem for Chelsea, who recorded the group's lowest revenue in the past two seasons.