Beginners

How to Choose a Tipster: 8 Signs of a Reliable Record

On this page
  1. 1. A complete record of every tip
  2. 2. A meaningful sample size
  3. 3. Yield, not win rate
  4. 4. Odds you can actually get
  5. 5. Closing line value
  6. 6. Consistent, sensible staking
  7. 7. Honest about losing runs
  8. 8. Realistic claims and transparent business
  9. Red flags of tipster scams
  10. A quick checklist
  11. FAQ

Short answer: A reliable tipster has a complete, timestamped record of every tip over hundreds of bets, measures success in yield (ROI) rather than win rate, posts odds you can actually get, and makes realistic claims. Anyone promising guaranteed wins, sure bets or fixed matches is not a tipster – it is a scam.

1. A complete record of every tip

Every tip – winners and losers – should be published before kick-off, with the date, market, odds and stake. A record built from screenshots of winning slips proves nothing; deleted losers are the oldest trick in the industry.

2. A meaningful sample size

Short-term results are mostly luck. At average odds around 2.00, the random spread of a tipster's yield shrinks only slowly as the number of tips grows:

Number of tipsTypical luck swing in yield (±1 standard deviation)
100±10%
500±4.5%
1,000±3.2%
2,000±2.2%

A +15% yield over 100 tips could easily be luck. A +5% yield over 2,000 tips is far more convincing.

3. Yield, not win rate

Win rate without odds means nothing. A tipster who wins 70% of bets at average odds of 1.30 is losing money: 0.70 × 1.30 = 0.91, a 9% loss per bet. Another who wins 40% at 2.80 is making 12%. Always ask for:

Yield (ROI) = total profit ÷ total amount staked

Over a large sample, a long-term yield of 2–10% is excellent. Claims of 30%+ over hundreds of bets are almost always false or unsustainable. See value betting for why.

4. Odds you can actually get

Many tips are recorded at a price that disappears minutes after publication. If a tipster's odds are consistently higher than what you can find, your real results will be worse than their record. Check how quickly prices move after tips are posted.

5. Closing line value

Good tipsters regularly beat the closing line – the final odds before kick-off. If the odds on a tip usually shorten after it is published, the tipster is finding value. It is one of the best signs of genuine skill and appears long before profit becomes statistically clear.

6. Consistent, sensible staking

Results should be in units with a consistent staking plan. Tipsters who suddenly recommend "max bets" or double stakes after losses are gambling with your bankroll.

7. Honest about losing runs

Every profitable tipster has drawdowns. A record that shows only smooth growth, or a tipster who stops publishing after losses, is a warning sign. Look for a published profit graph that includes the bad periods.

8. Realistic claims and transparent business

Ask how the tipster earns money. Some are paid per new bookmaker account – they profit from your losses, not your wins. Prefer services that earn from their own product and publish performance openly.

This is the standard ABV Tips holds itself to: the app shows its performance statistics – yield, average odds, total picks and profit history – alongside every prediction's Quality Score, so you can judge the record yourself.

Red flags of tipster scams

  • "Guaranteed", "100% sure" or "fixed match" tips – fixed-match sellers are always scammers.
  • Pressure to pay quickly for "VIP" access or one-off "big games".
  • Screenshots instead of a full record.
  • Huge claimed win rates without odds or yield.
  • Losing tips quietly deleted from channels.
  • Asking you to bet large stakes or borrow money.

A quick checklist

QuestionGood answer
Is every tip published before kick-off?Yes, timestamped
How many tips are in the record?500+
What is the yield?Positive, realistic (2–10%)
Can I get the same odds?Yes, consistently
Do the odds shorten after tips?Usually
Are losing runs visible?Yes

FAQ

How do I know if a tipster is legit?

Check for a complete, timestamped record over several hundred tips, a realistic positive yield and odds you can actually get.

What is a good win rate for a tipster?

It depends entirely on the odds. Judge tipsters by yield (ROI), not by win rate.

Are paid tipsters worth it?

Only if their verified long-term yield exceeds what they charge and you can get their odds. Most paid tipsters do not meet this standard.

Are fixed match tips real?

No. People selling "fixed matches" are scammers.

More on how to bet sensibly: the complete beginner's guide and football betting strategies that work.